Grand Rapids in need of Management

LG McDonald · Apr 11, 2017

Nightmare xX said: ↑

Only reason why I do this approach, is if you have to much " manager approach " you can potentially have two extremely different views on how a team should be ran , and if that other said manager who in your opinion is better as a management role but maybe not the greatest at the game, you are then stuck with an untradeable player who is essentially bringing down a team for lack of a better term .

It might work for some people, but for me I prefer to do it this way . But to each their own!
Click to expand...

I am okay with it, because there is nothing that I can do to change it.

Some Pylon · Apr 11, 2017

LG McDonald said: ↑

That's fine.

I'll give you some examples based on this seasons NHL Owner's;

ANA, Kryss has had a few hard seasons in the NHL but has been a dedicated manager overall. He could be accepted to return to the AHL or CHL if he wanted.

ARI, Stick, Stew and Fox all have many seasons of NHL success stemming back to S16 and I believe 18 winning a cup. All three are top NHL players, therefore wouldn't be eligible for AHL and NHL management.

BOS, Colonel is a has made great strides in his first season NHL Owner. He would be a bubble guy based on this one season, and it would be determined if he could return to the AHL based on the overall strength of the AHL Managers.

BUF, A1 and Ryan 6 have been top level NHL players for several seasons. We have also seen A1 step in and clean up teams in the past. Both would only be eligible for NHL MGT.

CHI, JBT rough first season in the NHL but he has been an NHL player for several season now. He would also be a bubble player. His GM and AGM however have been career NHL players with success, both would be ineligible.

COL, Zincy and LOL both have been career NHL players with experience. Both would not be AHL eligible.

CBJ, Potsy has been a long time veteran owner whom has struggled to make the playoffs. I like him at the NHL level because he has consistency for several seasons competed right until the final day of the season. He would be a bubble guy that I am leaning towards being NHL only.

DAL, all three are new to the NHL MGT role and had very limited success. All three could probably benefit from a season or two at the AHL level.

DET, all three are successful NHL players and have had success in MGT. All three would be NHL only.

EDM, all three are successful NHL players and have had success in MGT. All three would be NHL only.

FLA, I know Stif is severing a ban, but him and Terry would be considered the guys whom are ONLY NHL MGT eligible.

LAK, These guys are extreme bubble guys for me seeing as they BOTH have had past NHL success, and AHL success. The last few seasons have not truly reflected that, but I do see them both as valued NHL assets at this time.

MIN, Strizzy and Con are both NHL career guys whom will only be NHL MGT eligible.

MTL, Greg has been an NHL guy for many season and will remain NHL MGT eligible only. SuperM is a good example of solid AHL MGT whom has jumped top the NHL level and has shown success. At this current time, with his experience and how he is playing, he too would be an example of a player whom would be NHL MGT eligible moving into next season.

NJD, all three are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

NYI, could use a few more seasons at a lower tier to gain experience. Would be eligible for any tier of MGT.

NYR, these guys are in the same boat as SuperM, and Colonel. Tehy could be argued as bubble guys, one hit wonders, but based on their season performance they are NHL MGT eligible only.

OTT, all three are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

PHI, both guys could return to the AHL if they wish.

PIT, both are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

SJS, all three are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

STL, all three are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

TBL, bubble guys. Obviously they won in the AHL, but I think with some patience and a few seasons of experience, they could be a top 10 team.

TOR, Taco would be an excellent NHL GM(due to position and experience) I am not opposed to him taking AHL MGT either. His GM I believe would benefit from being a manager at a lower tier.

VAN, all three are NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

WSH, BOTH are career NHL players whom will remain NHL MGT eligible ONLY

WPG, Entire roster is ONLY NHL MGT eligible

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

Those are the examples I can give. Is it perfect? No. Is it subjective? 100%. The goal is to promote our top managers to try out the NHL but still allow wiggle room. Let's say bake and pauly have a rough S27 and S28. That IMO would be grounds to let them return. Vice versa would be if Snoopy or someone else put a few solid seasons under their belt they become less eligible to return.

There are many factors we have to consider. The measure stick IMO right now is based on our two best AHL Managers, skill and manager wise(Fishin and Wags). Both should probably take a step up. The difference IMO is Fishin HAS NHL success whereby Wags has yet to test those waters. That is where I draw the line.

We also have some insane CHL talent that over time can help us in the NHL and AHL, therefore I do allowing those managers to step down is counter productive.

By all means, players like Chislet for example are welcome to the AHL, similar to how Chivs was. But that process needs to be one where they are acquired via Bidding. Then if those players wish to hold the paid AGM role, that is also 100% fair game.

That is where I stand right now on this topic. Same will argue the AHL misses out on experienced managers like Chislet, but my counter argument will always be "what is the cost to get Chislet". IF 4 good AHL Managers, whom are boarderline NHL 3rd lines but good AHL players and Managers decided they want to quit management due to top level NHL guys coming down, how does that help us overall? A 4-1 trade IMO weakens the pool more than it helps us.

Just food for thought. This isn't meant to appear to be a dictatorship, and I am not trying to discourage or through people under the bus. By no means do I feel Chislet's intentions were to harm the league. The point I am making is based on my experience, the voice of experienced NHL and AHL Managers and my staff's opinion, this is the best route for us to head for S27.
Click to expand...

May I ask about Hertz? He was a decent nhl player who wanted AHL MGMT, who last season only went for 500K, had a good playoff run then became the talk of the town before kids were crying in the chatbox claiming it wasn't fair..

LG McDonald · Apr 11, 2017

Some Pylon said: ↑

May I ask about Hertz? He was a decent nhl player who wanted AHL MGMT, who last season only went for 500K, had a good playoff run then became the talk of the town before kids were crying in the chatbox claiming it wasn't fair..
Click to expand...

Link his profile

x Fisher 81 · Apr 11, 2017

@Hertz x 18

x Fisher 81 · Apr 11, 2017

yo @Chislett 19 so You, me, and @The Gr8 Haxby taking an ahl team next seson. sounds good #FantasticBoys

Winston Payne · Apr 11, 2017

@Bitetto02

swiss97 · Apr 12, 2017

@swiss97

Stoner x 95 · Apr 28, 2017

@Detect Stealth

Archie2395 · Apr 28, 2017

Id love to opportunity to step up in the AHL and take management

Garis93 · Apr 29, 2017

Hi

JTresatti · Apr 30, 2017

LG McDonald said: ↑

Not a chance you get AHL management

Season 26 will be the last season we see succesful NHL players or managers take AHL GM roles.

If you wish to play in the AHL it'll have be through bidding.
Click to expand...

Will this sort of thinking be implemented on the PSN side?

LG McDonald · Apr 30, 2017

JTx412 said: ↑

Will this sort of thinking be implemented on the PSN side?
Click to expand...

as of right now no

Log in or Sign up

Grand Rapids in need of Management

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

Some Pylon Some Pylon

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

x Fisher 81 @IslesGT RW

x Fisher 81 @IslesGT RW

Winston Payne Staff Emeritus

swiss97 Pepsi Guy

Stoner x 95 Well-Known Member

Archie2395 Well-Known Member

Garis93 and they don't stop coming

JTresatti Kobe

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

Log in or Sign up

Grand Rapids in need of Management

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

Some Pylon Some Pylon

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

x Fisher 81 @IslesGT RW

x Fisher 81 @IslesGT RW

Winston Payne Staff Emeritus

swiss97 Pepsi Guy

Stoner x 95 Well-Known Member

Archie2395 Well-Known Member

Garis93 and they don't stop coming

JTresatti Kobe

LG McDonald Director of Hockey Operations

Useful Searches